UNRWA failed its purpose | Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle

UNRWA failed its purpose

By Jonathan Friendly

In 1950, to great fanfare, the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) set up shop in Gaza, the West Bank, Jordan and Lebanon. The agency was to provide help for the 700,000 or so Arabs who had left their homes in Israel when the Arab nations went to war to destroy the infant Jewish state.

It was supposed to be a temporary activity, something that would offer some help to these homeless people until a permanent solution could be found — maybe with their being assimilated into countries like Lebanon and Jordan and Egypt. After all, an almost equal number of Jews had found homes in Israel after being kicked out of their homes in those same Arab countries when the war began.

It just didn’t work that way, and UNRWA has shattered the record for the longest-lasting and most one-sided agency that any group of nations has ever underwritten. It may also retire the trophy for being among the least effective of all those hapless groups that operate under U.N. auspices.

It has long since lost sight of the original goal of encouraging the Arab states to assimilate the Palestinians in their midst and has become a great cheerleader for the idea of a Palestinian state. So much of one, in fact, that it repeatedly turns a blind eye to Palestinian terrorism, preferring to rail about the damage done by Israel’s defensive operations that are intended to halt the fanatics before they strike again.

The blindness is understandable when you remember that UNRWA has grown into a mini-empire of 25,000 employees, almost all of them Palestinians, and a $300 million budget.

It is the major provider of schools, food and other social services in what it calls the refugee camps, but which are really permanent communities of two- and three-story houses. It exercises enormous political power but, as in all Arab communities, it is neither elected nor accountable to the people it is supposed to serve.

Ordinary Palestinians could legitimately complain that the five decades of UNRWA caretaking has left them poorer, hungrier and less educated than they were in 1948. But they don’t get to vote on that, and the United Nations seems not to care about the massive mission failure. It is easier and more fashionable to blame the Jews than to ask tough questions of UNRWA’s commissioner-general, Peter Hansen.

Some small ray of hope, however, is visible for those who think it is time to hold the agency accountable. UNRWA is currently running about $7 million in the red, and its annual “emergency appeal” for donations is getting about half as much as it wants. Maybe the nations are beginning to decide what Israel has long known: UNRWA has never gotten it right and never will.

Jonathan Friendly is contributing editor at Jewish Renaissance Media.