Beth Israel, Sinai pioneer use of innovative Israel program | Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle

Beth Israel, Sinai pioneer use of innovative Israel program

Rabbis David Cohen of Congregation Sinai and Jacob Herber of Congregation Beth Israel come from different Jewish religious movements — Reform and Conservative, respectively.

But they agree that the relationship Jews in the United States have with Israel, and with each other about Israel, needs to be transformed.

“The conversation has grown so polarized over the past years, it’s difficult for people to stay in the same room together when the issue of Israel comes up,” Cohen said to The Chronicle on Dec. 15 in a telephone interview from the Union of Reform Judaism’s biennial general assembly in Washington, D.C. “It is greatly troubling to me.”

“We believe it is vitally important for the Jewish community of North America to be engaged with Israel and to have a constructive and healthy relationship with Israel,” Herber said in a telephone interview on Dec. 14.

And because they are both among the senior rabbinical fellows of the Jerusalem-based Shalom Hartman Institute who studied there this past summer, they learned that the institute had finished creating a project aimed at addressing these issues.

Called “Engaging Israel,” it seeks “to respond to growing feelings of disenchantment and disinterest toward Israel among an ever-increasing number of Jews worldwide by creating a new narrative regarding the significance of Israel for Jewish life,” according to its website (iengage.org.il).

“This narrative will serve as a foundation for a new covenant between Israel and world Jewry, elevating the existing discourse from one with a crisis-based focus to one rooted in Jewish values and ideas,” the website description continues.

‘Crisis narrative’

The program’s creators — who include Rabbi Donniel Hartman, president of the Shalom Hartman Institute — contend that the Diaspora-Israel relationship had been premised on a “crisis narrative.”

“In this narrative, Jewish existence, both in Israel and around the world, was viewed as threatened by inevitable and often imminent danger,” the website states. “This inspired the creation of a Jewish identity in which the survival and perpetuation of the Jewish people and the defense of Jews in danger became central values.”

Today, the prosperity and relative security of Diaspora communities have combined with Israel’s prosperity and demonstrated military prowess to make this narrative less plausible and compelling, states the website. Therefore, “it becomes increasingly difficult to portray Israel as a weak country in dire need of help from Jews around the world.”

Therefore, “Now is the time to invite Jews from around the world to engage in thinking about the meaning that Israel can have in their lives and how they can be enriched and positively influenced by the reality of a Jewish nation. Only a narrative that gives meaning to Jewish statehood and sovereignty and that articulates a vision of Israel that lives up to the highest standard of Jewish values, morality, and democracy can form the basis for a new covenant for Jews around the world.”

Cohen and Herber were so impressed by this program that they decided to bring it to their congregations in Milwaukee. That makes them among the first rabbis in North America to use Engaging Israel.

“What I find most promising about the program is that it’s a corrective to the polarization that’s occurred in the American Jewish community on the topic of Israel over the past years,” said Cohen. “We’re not talking about history and politics, but rather how Jewish tradition informs many of the basic issues of Jewish life in Israel.”

Indeed, at the beginning of the seventh of the 12 sessions of Milwaukee’s first Engaging Israel program, which was held at Beth Israel on Dec. 13 (the first six were held at Sinai), Herber reiterated to the some 40 people participating that the program is “not about Israel advocacy or public relations,” nor about a specific “political point of view or ideology.”

“It focuses on Jewish values and respectful, pluralistic discussion,” he said.

And the program appears to be succeeding. Certainly all the participants this writer saw on Dec. 13 were able to “stay in the same room” and discuss the session’s topic, “Morality on the Battlefield” in relation to Israel’s fight against terrorist organizations.

Other subjects of the program — which began on Oct. 25 and is scheduled to conclude Feb. 7 — include Jewish religion and peoplehood, Judaism and democracy, and religious pluralism.

Some of the participants told this writer about how much they have learned from this program. Both Bud Siegel, 86, and his son-in-law, John Krahn, 46, members of Beth Israel, used the word “enlightening” to describe the program.

“I am finding it fascinating [and] I’m just soaking it up,” said Krahn. “I love the dialogue that is taking place.”

And Eti Ganin, a Sinai member who came from Israel and chairs Sinai’s Israel committee, said she was especially pleased that the materials provided by the Hartman Institute included filmed interviews with and writings by Israeli experts. The Dec. 13 session featured Moshe Halbertal, a philosopher who helped create the Israel Defense Force code of ethics.

“It’s not coming from outside, but from inside,” Ganin said. “That’s important for me.”

Cohen and Herber said they were very pleased by the turnout — as many as 60 people have attended a session, from the two congregations and from the community at large — and by the effect.

“I’ve seen through this unique approach… that there’s a heightened level of understanding, and a new vocabulary people have and a new perspective and tools at their disposal to help them resolve and reconcile the divide between their liberal American values and their Jewish values, and what is happening on the ground in Israel,” said Herber.

Moreover, said Herber, “It’s wonderful for the congregations to collaborate on an issue like this. I think it’s really great for the community.”