Synagogues pair up for trip to U.S. Holocaust museum | Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle

Synagogues pair up for trip to U.S. Holocaust museum

The atmosphere was one of expectation as 40 eighth, ninth and tenth grade students, parents, rabbis and others met early in the morning on Tuesday, March 13, at Gen. Mitchell International Airport.

But the group — from Mequon shuls Beth El Ner Tamid Synagogue and Congregation Agudas Achim Chabad — was headed for the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, D.C. It was the fourth such trip organized by Beth El, but its first in cooperation with another synagogue.

And moods changed even on entering the museum. Past the doors is a large, open atrium built of dull, lightly colored red bricks supporting cold-looking steel beams. Subtract the well-fed, brightly clad visitors milling about, and one feels as though one is entering a concentration camp.

As Jana B. Plotkin, a tenth grader from Beth El who visited the museum previously, said, “I don’t know of anybody who leaves with a smile on their face.”

She was right. By the end of the tour, the group seemed emotionally exhausted.

Maia Jacobs, an Agudas Achim student who traveled as part of the synagogue’s post bat-mitzvah group, said the museum tour “made me really sad…. Some of the videos and pictures were hard to look at,” but it was gratifying that the museum “kept the people’s memory alive.”

Having the students accompanied by a parent, rabbi or mentor was deemed necessary by Patricia Chamoy, president of Beth El and trip organizer, because of the graphic nature of the museum.

“The first time I took my kids to the Holocaust museum they just wanted to go home,” Chamoy said. “[They] need to do this when they are still amenable to going with a parent.”

The smell of death

“I’ve been to Vietnam and saw war atrocities, but this [museum] still tears me up,” said Beth El member Kim Queen. “I’ve never seen the devastation that I’ve seen here.”

Queen, who had been to the museum previously, said, “Each time I notice something different…. Today it was the pile of shoes. People asked, ‘What is that smell?’ [when passing by the exhibit] and I said, ‘It is the smell of death.’”

Since Rabbi Gideon Goldenholz, spiritual leader of Beth El, was making his third trip to the musem, he was “able to go through a little slower,” he said.

Goldenholz said he was heartened by some of the comments he heard from various visitors to the museum, many of whom were not Jewish, but also concerned by the reaction of others, which at times seemed inappropriately lighthearted.

Realizing that teaching about the Holocaust was necessary, Goldenholz still had reservations about the efficacy of such lessons.

“While I’m proud of America for being willing to put the museum in such a prominent position, what lessons will people draw from this?” he said. “[W]hat has the world really learned from this? Jews were murdered wholesale … but what transpired as a result? A few token people were punished.”

On the return flight, Rabbi Mordechai Spalter of Agudas Achim sat looking over information about the fate of his grandfather — a survivor — that he was able to download from a computer at the museum. “It was amazing,” he said. “I can’t get it out of my mind.”

Spalter said he was “angry” about the Holocaust, but also “fearful that this could happen again…. Jews should be one people. The only way to protect ourselves is to stay strong.”

“I don’t like what the Germans did,” said Beth El ninth grader Matthew Rudman, “but I feel good about the non-Jews that helped Jews” during the Holocaust.

Rudman said the museum made him more proud as a Jew because “my people survived an experience like [the Holocaust]…. It makes me appreciate Israel more because it is a place where Jewish people can be free.”