Let us not be guilty of ‘underreach’ | Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle

Let us not be guilty of ‘underreach’

In Exodus 4, before Moses returns to Egypt to free the Israelites from slavery, we read about a curious and inexplicable incident:

“At a night encampment on the way, the Lord encountered him and sought to kill him. So Zipporah [Moses’ wife] took a flint and cut off her son’s foreskin…”

Who is the “him” whom the Lord encountered and sought to kill? (Most commentators agree that the “him” is Moses himself.) Why was Gershom the son of Moses not circumcised?

There are more questions in the whole passage, but to me, one of the most interesting elements is: Why is it Zipporah, the daughter of Jethro the priest of Midian, Moses’ non-Israelite wife, who undertakes to fulfill the brit milah, the ritual circumcision of their son?

This is, of course, an ancient paradigm, but don’t we see it in our own time, as well? How often today do the Jewish and non-Jewish spouses in an interfaith marriage bring up their children as Jews?

Or, even more frequently, how often does the non-Jewish spouse (most often the wife) undertake the principal responsibility for creating a Jewish home and bringing up the children as Jewish?

In fact, the existence of non-Jews accompanying the Jewish people and intertwining their fate with ours was a commonplace of ancient Israel. The Hebrew word ger, which today is used to signify a convert to Judaism, is actually used in the Torah to mean a “stranger” (i.e., a non-Israelite) who dwells in the midst of the Jewish people.

Moses named his son, mentioned in the above passage, Gershom, meaning “a stranger there,” “for I have been a stranger in a foreign land” (Exodus 2:22).

We are told, “The stranger who resides with you shall be to you as one of your citizens; you shall love him as yourself, for you were strangers in the land of Egypt: I am the Lord your God” (Leviticus 19:34).

Not a radical idea

I felt perplexed by Rabbi Avi Shafran’s article about “outreach and overreach.” There is definitely ample precedent in the Jewish community for including non-Jews. It is not a radical idea.

But more importantly, I am not sure what Shafran suggests we do with those Jews who are intermarried or with those Jews who will never embrace a traditional observant Jewish life. Should we abandon them?

Or, worse, should we harangue them about the necessity of living properly Jewish lives until they, in humiliation and exasperation, abandon us? Or should we nurture them and include them in our community?

Shafran points out two stories from among the thousands of people who were “once non-observant Jews” who have embraced traditional Judaism.

I notice, however, that he doesn’t mention examples of the thousands of Jews brought up in observant homes who reject traditional Judaism, or even being Jewish altogether. I don’t need to tell any specific stories; we all can cite examples.

Don’t misunderstand me. I am happy for those people whose spiritual journey brings them to an observant life; I applaud them.

But, I am convinced that such a journey isn’t right for everyone. A person’s spiritual and Jewish journey is a complex thing.

The common conception is that a typical Jewish journey is from “secularism” to “observance” in a straight ascending line. Life journeys, however, are seldom that direct. They change and meander.

They are subject to all the foreseeable and unforeseeable events in a Jewish life: adulthood, separation, love, marriage, children, success, tragedy.

There are times in one’s life when one feels more connected to the Jewish community, and times when one feels less. I am thankful that the Jewish community offers diverse alternatives.

I agree with those ridiculed by Shafran who say that we need to create a Jewish community that encourages “inclusiveness, pluralism, and a welcoming atmosphere.”

In a world in which upwards of 55 percent of “Jewish” marriages are intermarriages, we need to welcome more actively those families and encourage them to bring up Jewish children.

Perhaps in a nurturing and inclusive Jewish society, more non-Jewish partners will, in fact, be encouraged to convert and to embrace Jewish life.

In any case, intermarriage is here to stay. In a world in which we teach our children that all humans are equal, and in which Jews have unprecedented freedoms in spite of being a minority, it is inevitable that many of us will meet and fall in love with non-Jews and make them our life partners.

In fact, if we do the math, we realize that for every two Jews that marry each other, we create one Jewish family, while for every two Jews who intermarry, we create, potentially, two families in Israel.

Our challenge is to work with the reality, and nurture it to create a vibrant and more committed Jewish community, and a rich and more meaningful Jewish life.

Shafran may believe that Jewish communities, or at least Jewish congregations, need to be “pure,” and that Jews need to be brought to observance. His approach will bring many Jews to a sense of purity and meaning.

His congregation, if he has one, may refuse to admit intermarried families or non-Jews (a policy that is not embraced by all Orthodox congregations). They will have some success.
But I hope that those of us in other segments of the Jewish world will pick up the slack and help all Jews, even those who can not accept Shafran’s program, to find their places in a diverse and welcoming Jewish community.

Jody Hirsh is director of Judaic education at the Harry & Rose Samson Family Jewish Community Center.